Celebrated table

The Tickled Trout

Discover The Tickled Trout in Sheffield, a Good Food Guide Local Gem known for locally sourced British cooking and Italian-inspired gastropub dishes.

The story

The Tickled Trout Sheffield: Award-Winning Gastropub in Derbyshire

A former local reborn as a dining destination

The Tickled Trout in Sheffield operates as an independent gastropub that earned a Local Gem title from the Good Food Guide. Owner Chris Mapp purchased his old village pub in Barlow and rebuilt it into a dining destination where seasonal sourcing defines the British cooking. The kitchen focuses on ingredient origins, relying on nearby Derbyshire farms and morning-caught Cornish seafood. This direct supply chain shapes every plate on the menu.

Seasonal plates and cross-channel influences

Diners frequently order the sea bream prepared with sea vegetables, chive mash, and a sharp dill sauce. The kitchen also embraces mild Italian inspirations through crispy-edged sourdough pizzas topped with Lancashire Blue cheese. Hearty staples like the Derbyshire pie with red wine jus sit comfortably alongside freshly fried arancini. Sticky toffee pudding paired with malt ice cream consistently rounds out the meal.

Ground-floor hospitality and private gatherings

The venue balances polished dining service with a relaxed bar culture where families and locals alike feel welcome. Classic wooden furnishings and a spacious function room separate quieter celebrations from the main floor buzz. Staff maintain a straightforward approach that avoids airs and graces while handling daily covers. Regular pub quizzes keep the community connection steady throughout the year.

Recognition

Awards & accolades

2026
AA Rosettes
2 Rosette
2 Rosette
2026
The Good Food Guide
Local Gem

Details

At a glance

AA Rosettes 2026 — 2 Rosette
The Good Food Guide 2026 — Local Gem
Cuisines English
Services Bar, Catering, Cocktails, Delivery, Dinner, Events, Farm To Table, Gastropub, Lunch, Meal Kits, Outdoor Seating, Parking, Private Chef, Private Parties, Private Room, Set Lunch Menu, Takeaway, Tasting Menu, Vegetarian, Wi-Fi, Wine Pairing

History

On the record

2026
AA Rosettes — 2 Rosette

2 Rosette Award for Culinary Excellence

2026
The Good Food Guide — Local Gem

It may lean towards the dining side of the pub scale, but this independent hostelry also has a bar area when drinkers can explore the hefty wine list and gin selection. Sunday roasts and dishes such as sea bream with salty sea vegetables, dill sauce and chive mash come in for praise, although the kitchen is also inspired by Italy. Expect arancini, garlicky dough balls, pastas and pizzas with crispy-edged sourdough bases and gently anglicised toppings – note the Lancashire Blue cheese in the quattro formaggi. To finish, the sticky toffee pudding deserves a medal, especially when teamed with malt ice cream. Staff help to create a welcoming atmosphere 'with no airs and graces'.

Established

Location

Find us

33 Valley Road, Barlow, Derbyshire, S18 7SL
Sheffield, United Kingdom
0114 289 1111
dine@tickledtroutbarlow.com
Visit website
Map showing The Tickled Trout